Understanding in a blog crash.
My apologies for my blog laying dormant for the past few days; I've been mostly disconnected from the internet, as the girlfriend and I spent the weekend visiting my parents, going to a wedding reception in the middle of nowhere, dealing with something like 14 inches of rain in Chicago in under two days, watching the Bears lose to Carolina (oh, come on! How did we blow a 17-3 lead?!?), seeing WALL-E (finally! This movie was too cute), etc. etc. etc.
Anyway, I am back now, and I have a few small thoughts (and one big explanation) for you.
1. The driver of the CTA bus I took Friday afternoon had a tattoo visible on his forearm that said "BORN TO KILL." Maybe the dude was just a big fan of Full Metal Jacket; I don't know. But that seems like a really bizarre thing to have inked on your body for eternity. And the choice to purposely roll your sleeve up so every passenger would see your tat upon paying fare? Either positively genius or unbelievably stupid.
2. Do I look like any of these people, all of whom are apparently named Tom King? After the reception on Saturday, the under-30 crowd moved the party to a local bar, and as I sat there enjoying my glass of water, two middle-aged men in suits walked in and immediately began waving at me. Thinking they were waving at someone behind me (as I obviously did not know these dudes), I ignored them. They then walked up to me and said, "Excuse me, you're Tom King, right?" I then had to break the news that I was not, in fact, Mr. King. The only question is, did the men mistake me for 19th century boxer Tom King, Olympic gold medalist sailor Tom King, or fictional British soap opera character Tom King? (Personally, I'm hoping it was the boxer.)
3. I have not gotten anyone fired from anything in my life. Last week, Dillinger Four's new album, C I V I L W A R, leaked, allegedly due to one person who was sent an advance online stream of the album by Fat Wreck Chords as they worked for a magazine (not AP) and then decided to share it with friends, who then shared it with more friends, who then posted it on various message boards around the internet, until someone tech-savvy enough decided to rip the streaming audio into MP3s and release the record for free to whoever wanted to use the bandwidth to grab it.
Not only is this illegal, it is immoral and immature.
When I asked a friend who worked for Fat where they think the leak came from, they pinpointed it to one specific person from a specific magazine (again, not AP) who had been begging them to hear the record. Upon hearing this person's name, I realized that same person had been emailing and IMing me incessantly for the past few weeks about trying to write for AP, and while his work was okay, I didn't believe it was up to par for our magazine, so I more or less didn't follow up with him, hoping he would get the point. Once I found out the label was holding him responsible for the leak, I promptly wrote him and let him know that AP doesn't use writers who leak records, so I would not need his services. This is a decision we've made at AP for a number of reasons, most notably being we would be held liable if a record we assigned to someone for review was leaked. Luckily, there have been very few instances of this happening since I've worked at AP, and we've tried to keep it that way.
Here's where the story gets wacky: Unbeknownst to me, the magazine which this guy worked for found out he was the alleged leaker, and they canned him. Somehow, this fact spreads across the internet as "Scott Heisel got [dude's name] fired." This is 100% false -- there is a long, long, long way to go from alerting Fat that the D4 stream had leaked (which I did, in hopes they could try and contain it) and getting someone fired from their job because they made an incredibly poor decision (which I did not do). This is the power of the internet: People don't want to actually seek out the truth; they'd rather have it handed to them in bite-sized nuggets on message boards and in comments of stories on music news websites. So let this be my feeble attempt to set the record straight. It probably won't help any, but at least I've told what little story there actually is. (If you want to read the alleged leaker's account of the events (as well as a whole bunch of digs at yours truly), you can do so here.)
If anyone out there still has any questions about this non-issue, feel free to leave them in the replies and I will be happy to answer them.
There. That's done with. Now, back to listening to this totally awesome Thursday/Envy split CD (Tim, you were right, this thing utterly kills). Time to go pre-order the vinyl!
Anyway, I am back now, and I have a few small thoughts (and one big explanation) for you.
1. The driver of the CTA bus I took Friday afternoon had a tattoo visible on his forearm that said "BORN TO KILL." Maybe the dude was just a big fan of Full Metal Jacket; I don't know. But that seems like a really bizarre thing to have inked on your body for eternity. And the choice to purposely roll your sleeve up so every passenger would see your tat upon paying fare? Either positively genius or unbelievably stupid.
2. Do I look like any of these people, all of whom are apparently named Tom King? After the reception on Saturday, the under-30 crowd moved the party to a local bar, and as I sat there enjoying my glass of water, two middle-aged men in suits walked in and immediately began waving at me. Thinking they were waving at someone behind me (as I obviously did not know these dudes), I ignored them. They then walked up to me and said, "Excuse me, you're Tom King, right?" I then had to break the news that I was not, in fact, Mr. King. The only question is, did the men mistake me for 19th century boxer Tom King, Olympic gold medalist sailor Tom King, or fictional British soap opera character Tom King? (Personally, I'm hoping it was the boxer.)
3. I have not gotten anyone fired from anything in my life. Last week, Dillinger Four's new album, C I V I L W A R, leaked, allegedly due to one person who was sent an advance online stream of the album by Fat Wreck Chords as they worked for a magazine (not AP) and then decided to share it with friends, who then shared it with more friends, who then posted it on various message boards around the internet, until someone tech-savvy enough decided to rip the streaming audio into MP3s and release the record for free to whoever wanted to use the bandwidth to grab it.
Not only is this illegal, it is immoral and immature.
When I asked a friend who worked for Fat where they think the leak came from, they pinpointed it to one specific person from a specific magazine (again, not AP) who had been begging them to hear the record. Upon hearing this person's name, I realized that same person had been emailing and IMing me incessantly for the past few weeks about trying to write for AP, and while his work was okay, I didn't believe it was up to par for our magazine, so I more or less didn't follow up with him, hoping he would get the point. Once I found out the label was holding him responsible for the leak, I promptly wrote him and let him know that AP doesn't use writers who leak records, so I would not need his services. This is a decision we've made at AP for a number of reasons, most notably being we would be held liable if a record we assigned to someone for review was leaked. Luckily, there have been very few instances of this happening since I've worked at AP, and we've tried to keep it that way.
Here's where the story gets wacky: Unbeknownst to me, the magazine which this guy worked for found out he was the alleged leaker, and they canned him. Somehow, this fact spreads across the internet as "Scott Heisel got [dude's name] fired." This is 100% false -- there is a long, long, long way to go from alerting Fat that the D4 stream had leaked (which I did, in hopes they could try and contain it) and getting someone fired from their job because they made an incredibly poor decision (which I did not do). This is the power of the internet: People don't want to actually seek out the truth; they'd rather have it handed to them in bite-sized nuggets on message boards and in comments of stories on music news websites. So let this be my feeble attempt to set the record straight. It probably won't help any, but at least I've told what little story there actually is. (If you want to read the alleged leaker's account of the events (as well as a whole bunch of digs at yours truly), you can do so here.)
If anyone out there still has any questions about this non-issue, feel free to leave them in the replies and I will be happy to answer them.
There. That's done with. Now, back to listening to this totally awesome Thursday/Envy split CD (Tim, you were right, this thing utterly kills). Time to go pre-order the vinyl!






















11 Comments:
(Scott Heisel: If anyone out there still has any questions about this non-issue, feel free to leave them in the replies and I will be happy to answer them.)
So can I write for AP since that guy is out of the running?
i just went and read his posts on you and the situation. And this guy has no sense, no integrity, and is a straight up dick.
he says he is a not a name dropper and yet he drops names through out the entire post
Scott please dont let your self get consumed in this scandal. I respect you and AP too much for this weasel to interfere
Thank you Scott for having integrity and journalism talent.
I want to be a music journalist and you ( not that failure) is who i will model my carrer after.
i pick team scott
To lafever:
If you want to write for me, email me three reviews, between 130 and 150 words long, of recently released albums that fit into the AP spectrum. They don't all need to be positive; in fact, I prefer them to be of differing opinions just to showcase your range. Email them to me at heisel [at] altpress [dot] com and if I like your writing, I'll be in touch.
Same goes for anyone else reading this.
Well, since I was unaware that you were, well, aware of it, I did the same thing. Emailed Fat and called several of the head Racket peeps to decide on a game plan. As I had no idea you were involved, the decision to fire Aaron came from me and me alone. Sorry you got caught up in this, hombre.
-Jonathan
Did you tattle to the teacher when you got called in the schoolyard, too?
Yeah, I get it, they're your friends (heaven knows you have name-dropping Tourette's), but still. Not your concern. You're not an employee, you're not liable through punknews anymore. I know your nose is already up the ass of whatever flash-in-the-pan scene band is this week (paging Bring Me the Hairspray, As I Lay Dying in a Poisoned Well While Ashes Swirl On Thursday Darkest Hour) - no reason to put their brown stick in Fat Mike's patootie, too.
Christ I can't spell. *stink
Also, *called names. You know, like tubby, scraggly, etc.
Look, I agree with you.
But you misunderstand where my frustration with the situation comes from. I've went on the defensive for you, hundreds of times now, because I'm pretty sure you didn't so shit.
Outside of that man, the only umbridge I take is that you gave my name on VC, and Ben took that down. Thats all, man.
It's ridiculous that people blame you for my actions. I apologize, earnestly for that. You did nothing to deserve all this recent outcry, Scott.
But thats where this needs to end.
It's my fault, not yours. Thats it.
if it was actually a "non-issue", would you have said a thing? Way to help Mitch Clem and the rest of the internet blow this up into a big deal. I'm sure Dillinger Four are PSYCHED to work with you in the future, you useless, fat piece of shit
there's somethin i don't like about heisel
"I more or less didn't follow up with him, hoping he would get the point. Once I found out the label was holding him responsible for the leak, I promptly wrote him and let him know that AP doesn't use writers who leak records, so I would not need his services."
If this were a non-issue, as you claim at the end of your post, and you had already decided both to pass on the leaker's services and that ignoring him was the best way to make this known to him, then "promptly" writing him about the incident was an unnecessary, dickheaded thing to do.
You sir, are an internet bully. I hope it was just as satisfying for you as it was for the linebacker when he beat the piss out of you for dressing weird in high school. Then again, things have changed in punk rock this past decade. Maybe you WERE the linebacker.
In summation: Thursday has always sucked.
P.S. For the record, I don't know the leaker and agree that his writing isn't all that great. My opinions have nothing to do with him.
Post a Comment
<< Home