[Photo by: YouTube/American IdolThe Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon/YouTube]

American Idol contestant Jonny Brenns shared his take on a Panic! At The Disco classic—”This Is Gospel”—last night. And safe to say, reactions to his performance have been… mixed.

Read more: P!ATD’s Brendon Urie and Joey Graceffa had the most amazing Twitter exchange

The final 14 contestant did impress the judges, and you can check out the performance for yourself below:

But Brenns' take on “This Is Gospel” got mixed reviews from Panic! fans on Twitter:

What did you think of the American Idol performance? Comment below and let us know!

Watch more: Panic! At The Disco's BEST AP Moments