Earlier this week, the internet resurrected the conspiracy theory that claims Avril Lavigne is dead, and the internet was (and still is) freaking out.

Now Lavigne posted a photo to Twitter, and the conspiracy theorists are diving right in to dissect the meaning of the social media post. Check out the photo update and response below!

Read more: This Avril Lavigne conspiracy theory has returned, and the internet is freaking out

Yesterday, Avril posted this indistinguishable photo on social media:

And although you can tell it’s Avril (or as theorists say, Melissa), the internet responded with as much enthusiasm as the original theory post itself.

The theory, explained in massive detail by Twitter user @Givenchyass, states that Lavigne died in 2003, and it’s her look-alike that has been living in her place since then. Her tweet thread shares all the “peculiar signs,” specifically regarding her change in appearance that just seems off. Check out the response to the original theory here.

Now we’ll just wait to see if Avril (or Melissa?) responds to the rumors.

Read more: 11 totally bonkers music conspiracy theories

What are your thoughts on the conspiracy? Let us know in the comments below!