Jack White, prolific rocker and current resident of Nashville, has long been absent at his neighborhood’s annual potluck gathering. That changed this week, however, as he finally made an appearance—and nobody there recognized him, (via ConsequenceOfSound).

Read more: Jack White addresses that whole guacamole incident

A separate attendee, whose mother helped put on the potluck, shared the comical story through Instagram. “At the bottom of our street, there is a large gated historic home shrouded in trees. We’ve never really spotted that neighbor. But we have from time to time heard guitar coming from the garage.” He continued, “This year, without warning, the occupant decided to come mingle with the neighbors. Of course they had no idea who he was. ‘Jack White, nice to meet you.’ He apologized for traveling so much and missing out over the years.”

Only Mr. White, right? You can check out the post for yourself below.

This picture is incredible. My sister texted it to me. Listen to this. My mom helps put on a neighborhood potluck in front of my childhood home. Our little dead-end street is populated primarily with older and quiet people. The houses are modest and suburban. My neighborhood has been doing this potluck for over a decade. At the bottom of our street, there is a large gated historic home shrouded in trees. We've never really spotted that neighbor. But we have from time to time heard guitar coming from the garage. This year, without warning, the occupant decided to come mingle with the neighbors. Of course many of them had no idea who he was. "Jack White? nice to meet you." He apologized for traveling so much and missing out over the years. #lifeiswonderful by @making_dinner #lookatthesepeople #theyhavenoidea #notelvisdontcare

A photo posted by Jedidiah Jenkins (@jedidiahjenkins) on