Panic! At The Disco just wrapped up an incredible career-spanning set at AT&T’s NCAA March Madness Music Festival.

Read more: Brendon Urie subtly revealed if he would ever reunite with former Panic! At The Disco members

In light of it being April 1, frontman Brendon Urie decided to have some fun and pull what was possibly the great emo prank of all time.

Instead of jumping into the next song on their setlist, the band started playing Fall Out Boy’s “Sugar, We’re Going Down.” 

Watch: Dancing demon Brendon Urie turns up harder than you ever will

Urie ended the charade with a candid, “April Fools motherfuckers.”

You can check out a fan-shot video of the epic prank below. Well played, gentlemen, well played.

[Photo cred: Graham Fielder]

Watch more: APMAs 2015: Panic! At The Disco perform “Hallelujah”