Have you caught Netflix‘s spooky new Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina yet? And have you ever wondered what the original cast of the Melissa Joan Hart-led TV series would think of the spine-chilling revival? Well, wonder no more.
Because the titular Spellman plus Harvey, Hilda and Zelda from ABC/The WB‘s beloved late-’90s/early 2000s Sabrina The Teenage Witch sat down with Netflix to share their reactions to the new program. And, no joke, it has them freaked!
Just watch below to see Caroline Rhea’s (Hilda Spellman) hilarious reactions to the scares. “It’s terrifying, this show!” she exclaims at one point. “It’s really scary. I don’t think I can watch it alone,” adds TV’s original Aunt Zelda, Beth Broderick.
As opposed to the old, family-friendly sitcom based on the Archie Comics characters, the new TV series is a supernatural horror tale with loose ties to Riverdale. And Mad Men alum Kiernan Shipka plays the lead character on the new show.
But don’t just assume that the stars watching each other’s shows is reciprocal. Shipka confesses she’s never seen the original Sabrina The Teenage Witch TV show in a recent interview promoting her role.
“I hadn’t seen much or any of the ’90s version just because it was a little bit before my time,” she tells The Washington Post. “I’m curious to see it. I definitely think one day I will go back and watch it. I sort of just wanted my own separate Sabrina.”
Were you as spooked by the Chilling Adventures as the O.G. Sabrina cast were to the new Netflix show? Relive the first trailer to the new series, right down below, and sound off in the comments section—we want to know what you think!